South African Police And MP’s Pinning Crime On Immigrants And Unemployment


On Tuesday 30 October 2018 South African Police representatives from five most dangerous precincts  were grilled in Parliament. Police station commanders were summoned to a session of figuring out the source of the crime rate.


The Portfolio Committee and the police commanders turned out having a back and forth session of criticisms over who is to blame for the high violent crime rates in Hillbrow‚ Johannesburg Central‚ Kagiso‚ Mitchells Plain‚ and Nyanga. Minister of Police Bheki Cele and Commissioner of Police Khehla John Sitole also attended the hearing.


There has been an increase in murder in all of them‚ with minor shifts in other categories of contact crime.The police blamed foreign nationals‚ unemployment‚ and gang activity for being the main impediments to reducing crime in the precincts.


A spokesperson for the Nyanga police station criticized the national representatives of South African Police Service (SAPS) for pushing blame onto the station. He cited a lack of resources and no proper national review by SAPS of the conditions under which people live for the failure to lower crime rates.


The SAPS presentation had a list called the Five Pillars‚ which actually listed six priorities for reducing crime. Intelligence gathering‚ pro-active approach‚ combat approach‚ reactive through detection approach‚ community policing‚ communication and liaison. None of these were properly explained.

Barrage of criticism

SAPS representatives delivered a presentation on the five precincts. Members of Parliament (MP’s) followed the presentation with questions that turned into a barrage of criticisms of SAPS.

Committee members condemned the fact that the five precincts have held their positions as the highest violent crime rate precincts for most of recent history. Focusing on the five precincts in question‚ one MP argued‚ change in precincts with slightly lower crime‚ such as Umlazi‚ was not occurring.

MPs chastised SAPS for failing to fight police corruption or address mediocre police performance. The committee also focused on statistics showing that in some precincts many employed officers are not reporting for duty‚ whether on sick leave or for family obligations or other reasons. In Mitchells Plain‚ only 79% of officers are currently reporting for duty.

MP Dianne Kohler Barnard (District Attorney ) said that while there are funds allocated for informants‚ there was no mention at any point of any informants being used. She suggested that the precincts may be committing fraud. Another MP pointed out that 76 bulletproof vests were reported missing from Johannesburg Central.

The meeting became heated when immigration was discussed. Representative Ahmed Munzoor Shaik Emam (NFP) delivered a diatribe over how some suburbs of the Western Cape are entirely occupied by foreign nationals‚ and how South Africa is not meant to host so many immigrants.

The response by the committee wrapped up with a long address by MP Livhuhani Mabija (African National Congress)‚ who had previously kept quiet. Mabija‚ speaking more to the entire room of people rather than the SAPS representatives‚ gave an emotional plea calling for the country to be saved. She argued that the root of the issue is not a lack of performance‚ but self-interest and money.

If all political parties don’t stop fighting for power, we cannot stop the criminals. We fail to love poor people. We fail to love one another.

Mabija defended the SAPS representatives said

We expect the poor men and women in blue to care for all this rubbish … if we don’t change the mindset of the masses‚ we won’t win.

Representatives from SAPS‚ with much less enthusiasm than before the questioning by the committee‚ responded morosely to the criticisms. They said they felt unfairly blamed for issues that were not theirs alone to address.


Cele laughed at the committee’s criticisms‚ claiming that the SAPS mission is impossible because “the conditions [of the precincts] will never change”.

Sitole said “SAPS mandate is overstretched and impossible to fill.” Sitole also argued that the true solution was not increased police enforcement‚ but “overall change of human life”.

The meeting then ended.

The only resolution from the meeting was that all vacancies in these five precincts be filled by December. MP Zakhele Mbele (DA) said there would be follow-up meetings next year to assess whether the resolution has been implemented.

This article was originally published by GroundUp.


Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.